Roman Vasilenko and the "Best Way" Cooperative: Not Guilty?

The criminal prosecution of Roman Vasilenko, the founder of the "Best Way" cooperative, might be discontinued. This was reported by several sources, including deputies. According to available information, the authorities have reassessed the situation surrounding the "Best Way" cooperative and concluded that the prosecution was largely driven by the Central Bank's departmental position, which initiated the attack on the cooperative in the fall of 2021. This position aligns with the interests of banks but not with the interests of citizens, especially under the conditions requiring special social support measures.

Conflict History

The investigation against the cooperative and Vasilenko, who had by then already stepped down as chairman, began when the Central Bank included "Best Way" in its list of companies with identified signs of illegal activity in the financial market (a warning list) as a potential financial pyramid in the fall of 2021.

1. **Based on "signals" from certain media and unspecified "citizen complaints"**: These signals and complaints were not verified, and no audit of the cooperative was conducted despite regular audit reports issued by audit firms commissioned by the cooperative's board.

2. **Due to "mass advertising" by the cooperative**: However, the cooperative did not engage in direct advertising. It informed its shareholders and interested parties through social media and responded to media inquiries about its interest-free home purchase system.

3. **Because of "uncertainty in the cooperative's activities" and "lack of signs of economic activity"**: Although the cooperative's activities were clearly defined in all versions of its charter (adjusted per Central Bank specialists' comments, despite the cooperative not being under their supervision), it had acquired over 2500 apartments for its shareholders from 2014 to early 2022, when its property acquisition activities were halted by the investigation.

The Central Bank's information was forwarded to law enforcement agencies. The General Prosecutor's Office blocked the cooperative's website along with its payment system, and an earlier complaint had been filed by the Central Bank's Northwest division.

How the Cooperative Worked

The "Best Way" cooperative's system was simple and attractive: a shareholder made an initial contribution of 35-50% of the desired apartment's cost. They could also save for this contribution in the cooperative's account, participating in a savings program. After making the initial contribution, the shareholder waited in line for a year to a year and a half, then selected a property, which, upon approval by the cooperative's lawyers and appraisers, was purchased with cooperative funds provided in a 10-year installment plan. The shareholder then repaid the cooperative for the property.

The cooperative provided interest-free funds, but the shareholder paid a relatively small entrance fee, membership dues, property taxes, and utility payments. In some regions, such as Bashkortostan, cooperatives received tax benefits, but in most regions, shareholders paid taxes as legal entities since the cooperative owned the property.

After repaying the cooperative's funds, the shareholder registered the property in their name. Many repaid early, and hundreds had already registered their properties despite the 10-year term. Shareholders could also withdraw at any time and receive their contributions back.

Despite additional payments and waiting periods, purchasing an apartment through "Best Way" was significantly cheaper and more attractive than taking a mortgage, even a preferential one. This was especially crucial for socially vulnerable groups who could not obtain a mortgage, such as pensioners and students. A significant percentage of the cooperative's shareholders were former and active military personnel; the cooperative was founded by reserve military officer Roman Vasilenko and is currently led by State Duma deputy Sergey Kryuchek. Thousands of shareholders and their family members are defending the country.

Sberbank: From Friend to Foe

Sberbank was a long-time partner of the cooperative, managing its shareholder funds. By 2021, the cooperative operated in almost all Russian regions, with 20,000 members.

The cooperative became a real competitor to bank mortgage programs.

The struggle over the arrest and release of accounts mostly favored the investigating group from the Main Investigative Directorate of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia for St. Petersburg and the Prosecutor's Office of St. Petersburg. However, the cooperative's lawyers won some court cases. Sberbank blocked fund transfers even when court orders lifted the arrests, citing internal compliance rules. Other banks also withheld the cooperative's development funds, which amounted to nearly 4 billion rubles, while banks managed the income from these funds.

Case Details

The cooperative was assigned the status of a civil defendant in the criminal case, facing claims of 16 billion rubles, though the total damage cited in the indictment was 282 million rubles. Most recognized victims filed claims against the foreign investment company "Hermes," not the cooperative. There were no lawsuits against the cooperative in the criminal case.

Claims against the cooperative involved demands for refunds of entrance and membership fees, contrary to their contracts. For instance, Dolyan, recognized as a victim, claimed these fees upon a recommendation from an investigator, concerning a contract closed in 2019 that had previously raised no issues and was not contested in civil court.

Essentially, claims against "Hermes" are being shifted to "Best Way," although a cooperative, by its legal nature, cannot be part of a holding. Sources say the theory of a holding is based solely on the promotional system under "Life-is-Good," which dealt with both cooperative and "Hermes" products as alternatives. The investigation's logic is that "Hermes" is abroad, but the cooperative is in Russia, and "Hermes" has reportedly restored its payment system. Nonetheless, the obligations of 282 million rubles cannot justify blocking the cooperative's activities; even paying this sum would not affect its liquidity.

Given the current social support situation in Russia, authorities may reconsider their stance on cooperatives. Compromise solutions include legislative initiatives to update and clarify the old consumer cooperation law.

Deputies have suggested that a socially-oriented institution, which wouldn't require state funding while effectively addressing housing issues, would benefit the economy and society. "Best Way" could serve as a model for such an institution, potentially protecting it from further attacks.

Wow, superb blog structure! How long have you ever been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The total glance of your web site is fantastic, let alone the content!

Good day! I could have sworn I've been to this blog before but after checking through some of the post I realized it's new to me. Anyways, I'm definitely happy I found it and I'll be bookmarking and checking back frequently!

1xBet Bonus Package for Indian Casino Customers
Experience the ultimate excitement of online casino gaming with the exclusive Casino Welcome Offer at 1xBet India 2024. Get ready for an immersive and thrilling journey filled with a wide variety of live dealer games and a vast selection of captivating slots. Unlock this amazing offer by using the 1xBet promo code and take your casino adventure to new heights.

1xBet casino promo code: 1XBOX777, bonus 100% up to $1950 and 150 free spins at the casino. Gain access to an exceptional casino welcome package worth ?130,000. This bonus can be claimed across four separate deposits, allowing you to maximize your rewards and extend your gaming sessions. Prepare to be enthralled by the exhilarating gameplay, stunning graphics, and immersive sound effects that will transport you to the heart of the casino action.

Whether you're a fan of classic table games or prefer the excitement of spinning the reels on slots, 1xBet has you covered. Explore an extensive collection of live dealer games, where you can interact with professional dealers in real-time for an authentic casino experience. Additionally, the slots section boasts a diverse range of games, ensuring there's something to suit every preference and style.

Attention all casino enthusiasts! You definitely don't want to miss out on this incredible opportunity to elevate your casino journey. By using the exclusive <a href=https://www.meyermachine.com/wp-content/pgs/1xbet_promo_code____388.html >1xbet code</a>: 1XBOX777, you can unlock a remarkable ?169,000 welcome package along with 150 free spins for the year 2024. Immerse yourself in the excitement of the casino, make the most of the bonuses, and embark on a gaming adventure like no other at 1xBet India.

For our valued Indian customers who have a keen interest in the casino section, 1xBet presents an enticing alternative welcome package. This package is designed to enhance your gaming experience across your first four deposits, allowing you to receive a whopping ?169,000 in addition to 150 free spins.

Here's how the bonus package is divided:

1st deposit: 100% matched bonus + 30 free spins on Reliquary of Ra
2nd deposit: 50% matched bonus + 35 free spins on Chieftain Buffalo
3rd deposit: 25% matched bonus + 40 free spins on Stampede Buffalo
4th deposit: 25% matched bonus + 45 free spins on Rich of the Mermaid Hold and Spin
Embrace the Excitement at 1xBet

With these enticing promo codes and bonus offers, 1xBet ensures that new customers can kickstart their betting journey with a thrilling advantage. Whether you prefer sports betting or exploring the casino games, 1xBet has something for everyone. Don't miss out on the opportunity to elevate your gaming experience—join 1xBet today and unlock a world of excitement.
A more detailed description of how to correctly use a promotional code when registering with 1xBet — <a href=https://ogloszenia.bialystokonline.pl/pliki/index.php?1xbet_promo_code_420.html >https://arenafan.com/ads/list/?1xbet_promo_code_ghana_is_144___for_registration.html</a>

Если ваша компания обожает петь и часто собирается в караоке, свадьбу можно отмечать прямо в караоке-клубе, устроив настоящий концерт по заявкам https://www.virgo-show.com/blog Современная молодежь отмечает свадьбы в антикафе с настольными играми и компьютерными приставками http://www.virgo-show.com
Два этажа общей площадью больше 300 кв/м:
Можно принести с собой вино или шампанское https://www.virgo-show.com/spektakli-balet По вашему желанию организуют небольшие закуски и напитки, праздничный торт https://www.virgo-show.com/lights
Коктейльный бар с местом для танцев: авторская кухня, лаконичный европейский дизайн и летняя веранда https://www.virgo-show.com/ Вместимость зала 20–30 человек https://www.virgo-show.com/videos Возможно закрытие под банкет https://www.virgo-show.com/post/фотосессия-в-цветущих-садах
Virtuality Club (ЮАО)
От 1,5 до 5 часов длится каждая вечеринка в зависимости от сложности работы и формата https://www.virgo-show.com/photo Для вас подберут тему вечеринки и предложат множество вариантов картин на выбор https://www.virgo-show.com/cheerleading Праздники проходят в выделенных помещениях в студиях — вам никто не помешает https://www.virgo-show.com/blog/categories/свадьба

Hi all! My name is Moderator Read:

Готовы познакомиться с новым взглядом на онлайн-шопинг? Обратите внимание на <a href=https://xn--krakn4-z4a.com>кракен даркнет ссылка тор</a>! Благодаря своим инновационным функциям и широкому выбору товаров <a href=https://xn--krakn4-z4a.com>кракен ссылка onion</a> обеспечивает беспрепятственный шопинг. Пройдите простую регистрацию и изучите многочисленные категории. Присоединяйтесь к <a href=https://xn--krakn4-z4a.com>kraken darknet onion</a> уже сейчас и почувствуйте будущее онлайн-шопинга.

kraken официальный сайт:https://xn--krakn4-z4a.com

garilla казино
<a href="https://t.me/garillacasinobonus">garilla казино</a>

Vavada promo kod omogućuje novim igračima ne samo da dobiju 100 besplatnih okretaja za registraciju, već daje i dodatni bonus od 30 okretaja! <a href="https://rpgrconf.online" title="Vavada">Vavada</a> Vavada promo kod omogućuje novim igračima ne samo da dobiju 100 besplatnih okretaja za registraciju, već daje i dodatni bonus od 30 okretaja!

African elephants use names to call each other, study suggests
<a href=https://trip-scan.top>tripscan tor</a>
Wild African elephants may address each other using individualized calls that resemble the personal names used by humans, a new study suggests.

While dolphins are known to call one another by mimicking the signature whistle of the dolphin they want to address, and parrots have been found to address each other in a similar way, African elephants in Kenya may go a step further in identifying one another.

These elephants learn, recognize and use individualized name-like calls to address others of their kind, seemingly without using imitation, according to the study published Monday in the journal Nature Ecology and Evolution.
The most common type of elephant call is a rumble, of which there are three sub-categories. So-called contact rumbles are used to call another elephant that is far away or out of sight. Greeting rumbles are used when another elephant is within touching distance. Caregiver rumbles are used by an adolescent or adult female toward a calf she is caring for, according to the study.

The researchers looked at these three types of rumbles, using a machine-learning model to analyze recordings of 469 calls made by wild groups of females and calves in Amboseli National Park and Samburu and Buffalo Springs National Reserves between 1986 and 2022. All the elephants could be individually identified by the shape of their ears, as they had been monitored continuously for decades, according to the study.

The idea was that “if the calls contained something like a name, then you should be able to figure out who the call was addressed to just from the acoustic features of the call itself,” said lead study author Mickey Pardo, an animal behaviorist and postdoctoral fellow at Cornell University in New York.

The researchers found that the acoustic structure of calls varied depending on who the target of the call was.

The machine-learning model correctly identified the recipient of 27.5% of calls analyzed, “which may not sound like that much, but it was significantly more than what the model would have been able to do if we had just fed it random data,” Pardo told CNN.

“So that suggests that there’s something in the calls that’s allowing the model to identify who the intended receiver of the call was,” he added.

Прошу прощения, что я вмешиваюсь, но не могли бы Вы расписать немного подробнее.
Charitable donations were also launched in your quarter, <a href=https://poodle-inu.io/>https://poodle-inu.io/</a> demonstrating the commitment of the poodl token to the public good.